New TV series “We Just Decided To” pilot review of The Newsroom

By Ron Peltier

The season premiere of HBO’s The Newsroom, “We Just Decided To,” promises strong things for the series. However, the show’s pilot is not without some minor flaws and issues germane to pilots.

The show centers on famous cable news anchor, Will McVoy, played by Jeff Daniels, and his newsroom staff. The episode begins as McVoy melts down at a conference discussion. He asserts several alarming facts about the US, challenging the popular notion of US supremacy. Such unvarnished veracity does not go down easy with American audiences.

After a vacation, he returns to work and finds his staff has all gone on to work for a different show and replaced by his boss, Charlie Skinner, played by Sam Waterson. The replacement staff includes his ex-girlfriend as the show’s executive producer, sending the mercurial news anchor into a rage. His ex-girlfriend, Mackenzie McHale, is played by Emily Mortier. There is a history between the two, which the show promises to tease out throughout the season.

One of the problems is that too much pedantic exposition occurs. Aaron Sorkin, whose impressive credits include Moneyball, The Social Network and the revered T.V. series The West Wing, is the show’s creator and episode writer. His work often provides lengthy speeches by smart characters. Several scenes serve to inform us of the importance of news and its relationship to democracy, the US and, more generally, freedom. These scenes have the feel of a lecture at times. However, it is setting up one of the essential conflicts—can news be profitable without compromising values?

The show works best when it’s frenetic and not preaching. The last half of the show works very well and portends strong things to come.

Before the new staff settles in, the BP Deep Horizon Oil Rig blows up, and the new staff must decide how to cover it. Is it just a search and rescue story or the worst environmental catastrophe in our history? Just like on The West Wing, characters move, think and talk quickly while the camera tries to keep up.

Various staff members discover important elements about the breaking news story and are able to convey the information just in the nick of time as McVoy relays the information on-air. It demonstrates the skill and competency of the new staff to both McVoy and the audience. Only a complete moron could miss that. All this is a little too convenient; it does work to set the show in motion, however.

There are several additional characters in the news room, and already there is a burgeoning love conflict between staffers. But the best thing about Sorkin’s work involves the witty banter between characters. Smart people engaged in smart discussion and repartee are often nowhere to be found on the TV landscape. And the pilot provides some clever quips.

The pilot has additional burdens that the on-going series does not. It has to introduce several characters and provide them with interests and personality. It must set the series in motion by revealing the tension and conflict. However, despite those concerns, “We Just Decided To” effectively provides a reason to keep watching to see just where things go. The show could be a lot of fun; we’ll have to wait and see.

One Response to New TV series “We Just Decided To” pilot review of The Newsroom

  1. oro usato December 26, 2012 at 5:10 am

    I have been absent for some time, but now I remember why I used to love this blog. Thank you, I will try and check back more frequently. How frequently you update your site?

    Reply

We will read your comment immediately so leave a remark!

RSS Guardian Express

  • Giancarlo Stanton Slam Gives Miami Win: Marlins Matters April 19, 2014
    Giancarlo Stanton hit a dramatic ninth inning walk-off grand slam to send the Miami Marlins to victory over the Seattle Mariners by a score of 8-4. The walk-off four-run homer was the fifth in Marlins history; the second by Stanton. Stanton’s home run may not have occurred, were it not for an overturned call that […]
    Robert Pannier
  • Gwen Stefani Will Replace Christina Aguilera for Season 7 of The Voice April 19, 2014
    Gwen Stefani of No Doubt will be joining Pharrell Williams as a judge in Season 7 of The Voice, replacing Christina Aguilera, who is pregnant, according to multiple sources. She has reportedly signed on for the upcoming seventh season of The Voice, which will begin taping this June, though there’s no word yet if she’ll […]
    Douglas Cobb
  • Carolina Panthers First Round Review: NFL Draft Daily [Video] April 19, 2014
    The Carolina Panthers had one heck of a season. Carolina made the playoffs for the first time since 2008, and it was their first division title since then as well. Cam Newton was consistently better at not turning over the ball as much in years past, and the defense put mediocrity aside for a season; […]
    Justin Huffman
  • Giancarlo Stanton Turning Into Most Feared Power Hitter in MLB April 19, 2014
    With one more titanic swing of the bat from Giancarlo Stanton’s hulking 6’6″ frame, the Miami Marlins slugger buried the Seattle Mariners 8-4 with a walk-off grand slam on Friday. It was the second walk-off slam in Stanton’s young career, and the fifth in Marlins’ history. The right fielder now leads the majors with six […]
    Justin Hussong
  • MLB Guardian Liberty Voice Power Rankings: Atlanta Braves on the Warpath April 19, 2014
    With the second best record in baseball, the Atlanta Braves find themselves in first in the Guardian Liberty Voice Baseball power rankings for week 3 of the MLB season. The Atlanta Braves have clearly been on the warpath, crushing the Washington Nationals last weekend in sweeping them, then taking two of three from the Philadelphia Phillies. […]
    Robert Pannier

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 626 other subscribers

Quantcast