27 Death Penalty Convictions May be the Result of FBI Errors


FBI_badgeAfter reviews of thousands of cases, the FBI has revealed that it may have made errors in 27 death penalty convictions.  Exaggerated testimonies may have resulted in wrongfully linking defendants to the crimes.

The investigation was launched as the result of a Washington Post article last year.  The publication questioned the validity of convictions related to ‘hair samples.’  The Post claimed that officials within the FBI knew of the possibility of erroneous information, but refused to correct it.

One year ago, the FBI agreed to review results of investigations which may have resulted in death penalty convictions.  They reviewed more than 21,700 laboratory files.  120 results were labeled as ‘suspicious,’ and 27 of those were death penalty cases.

The vast majority of laboratory results in question are related to ‘hair samples.’  The experts linked the samples and positively identified the link between the victim and an assailant.  However, in 1970, the FBI stated that hair samples alone may be inconclusive because the evidence is easily flawed.

The FBI says that there may be cases when a defendant was convicted solely on the evidence of hair samples, and in some cases given the death penalty.

“One of the things good scientists do is question their assumptions,” David Christian Hassell, director of the FBI Laboratory, told the Post. “No matter what the field, what the discipline, those questions should be up for debate. That’s as true in forensics as anything else.”

The Texas Forensic Science Commission has agreed to review the cases of its death row inmates.  Texas executes more inmates than any other state in the union, and has agreed to carefully scrutinize any cases where convictions were solely based on hair sample matches.

In May, Jerome Manning, a 44-year-old man who was convicted of murdering two college students in 1992, was given a stay of execution in Mississippi.  His death by lethal injection was abated while FBI investigators reviewed what they believe to be flawed forensic evidence.

There is no information regarding how many inmates may have been executed due to faulty evidence related to hair analysis.  There will be an announcement later this summer.

Meanwhile, the focus is prioritized towards death row cases.  Once they have all been reviewed, they will focus on other convictions which may have been based on evidence which should have been labeled ‘inconclusive.’

As of this moment, the FBI admits that 27 death penalty cases may be the result of evidence that was presented in error.

Alfred James reporting


We will read your comment immediately so leave a remark!

RSS Guardian Express

  • Autism and the Challenges of Easter April 18, 2014
    For most families living with an autistic loved one, everyday holds certain demands. Holidays, like Easter, provide even further challenges for those with autism. The traditions most people take for granted must be approached from a unique perspective. Zack, who is 11 years old, is moderate to high-functoning on the Autism Spectrum. He loves the […]
    Stacy Lamy
  • Peaches Geldof Funeral Arrangements Shared April 18, 2014
    The funeral arrangements for Peaches Geldof have been shared by her family. It will be a private funeral on Easter Monday (April 21), and will be held in the same church as her mother’s funeral. St. Mary Magdalene and St. Lawrence Church in Davington is also the same church that the 25-year-old socialite married and […]
    Alexandria Ingham
  • Game of Thrones Spoilers Ruining the Experience? April 18, 2014
    Sharing spoilers of Game of Thrones is ruining the experience for some people. They do not want to know what happens in the episodes before they get a chance to see it themselves. The issue reached its peak so far this week after many publications started sharing the events of the “Purple Wedding” just after […]
    Alexandria Ingham
  • Game of Thrones Spoilers Lead to Arguments Online April 18, 2014
    The internet has been surrounded with Game of Thrones spoilers this week that include the death of a certain character, and it has led to arguments online. Many people who have not read the books or seen the episode yet have gotten annoyed at publications for sharing the details of the character’s death, and even […]
    Alexandria Ingham
  • Miley Cyrus Hits Out at Hospital Rumors April 18, 2014
    Miley Cyrus has hit out at rumors suggesting her recent trip to hospital was due to her partying ways. A number of publications decided to jump on the idea that the 21-year-old was out partying in a way to get over the recent death of her dog, Floyd. In a statement, which she linked to […]
    Alexandria Ingham

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 626 other subscribers