Stephen Hawking Says No Black Holes Exist

Stephen Hawking No Black Holes Exist

Stephen Hawking is the most famous living scientist in the world and he gained much of his notoriety from the bizarre space objects known as “black holes.” Now Hawking is saying that no black holes exist in our universe.

A black hole is a theory from physicists that regions of space and time in our universe can become so dense that nothing can escape their grasp including light. The density increases until the huge gravity of a black hole eventually generates what is known as an “event horizon.” Stephen Hawking then took those theories and applied quantum mechanics to black holes back in 1974. Hawking’s point of view sparked much controversy in the scientific community and that controversy still continues today.

Generally, quantum mechanics does not play well with any other grand theories of general relativity or physics. It is even more complicated when combined in situations where both of the grand theories are relevant. When the quantum mechanics was applied to the theory of black holes, Hawking was able to determine that black holes are not actually black. However, what Hawking did find is that the phenomena will emit radiation in small quantities that would cause them to eventually shrink and evaporate.

The black hole radiation theory also made suggestions that when a black hole finally dies, it will take everything inside of it. However, this theory is disproved by quantum mechanics. According to physics information matter is never destroyed even if it is devoured by a black hole. Some other theories are that the black hole releases this information when it dries up and evaporates. Hawking disagreed with the theorists originally, but has now changed his mind by explaining how it just might be possible. It has taken him 30 years, but Hawking has now had to concede to a wager made seven years ago with another physicist.

Stephen Hawking is not the only scientist that finds controversy in the black hole theories. The University of California in Santa Barbara has such a group that is led by Joseph Polchinski. Polchinski’s group has a theory called the firewall paradox. The paradox is a descendant of the currently existing information paradox which suggests that the information that would normally be leaving a black hole would cause it to create and give off massive amounts of energy. This huge energy would create a wall of fire that would probably consume anything pulled into the black hole. This theory breaks the general rules of relativity which says that crossing an event horizon created from a black hole should be uneventful and create no issues.

Hawking now suggests that one of the two theories is wrong and by giving up the event horizon would prove one paradox correct and discount the other. This also means that it may be possible to escape from a black hole but one would have to be travelling the speed of light to successfully escape its grasp. Hawking says that removing the event horizon means that there is no such thing as a black hole. However, black holes may have “apparent horizons” where they are able to trap light and vary in shape by using quantum fluctuations. The changing of shape is when there is the potential for light to escape the black hole.

Roger Penrose from the University of Oxford agrees with Hawking’s theory and has also proved that event horizons and apparent horizons are actually identical. However, Penrose recently wrote a paper that proposes quantum mechanics may reveal the two horizons are actually different.

Also by removing the event horizon it removes the firewall paradox and suggests at the same time that the information would be lost. However, Stephen Hawking proposes that just below the horizon the structure of the black hole is quite chaotic and making it nearly impossible to understand any energy that is released but the information is not destroyed, just incomprehensible.

Stephen Hawking’s latest paper that was published about black holes is just two short pages of text and contained no actual calculations which make it impossible for anyone to verify Hawking’s conclusions. Some scientists disagree with Hawking as he does not really provide any concrete evidence to support his theory that no firewalls exist.

By Brent Matsalla

Sources:
Nature
New Scientist
Forbes

9 Responses to Stephen Hawking Says No Black Holes Exist

  1. Jaime March 26, 2014 at 12:56 pm

    IT says above that these are theories. That is why they say that anything is possible in science. If it wasnt for Benjamin Franklin with the crazy science you wouldnt have that lightbulb in your ceiling. Point being, we need science but part of that is failing. If you never fail you will never learn, if you never learn you will never succeed.

    Reply
  2. same as above February 19, 2014 at 2:20 pm

    I get a kick out of all these socalled intellectual’s like scientist Stephen Hawking. They make postulations that are just unproven theories. Theories are what a researcher observes from his/her own experiments and research puts the findings out there for individuals to prove or disprove. They are not ABSOLUTE LAWS. only THEORIES. All this gobbleguke about the how they think (postualte) on how the universe began is a bunch or intellectual bunk and rightly so as they keep contrdicting each other because they do not really know how the universe or time actually started. UGH! UGH!! UGH!!!

    Reply
  3. Mr H January 25, 2014 at 4:17 pm

    The headline of this article is completely misleading.
    And I would really like to know which of Einstein’s theories or relativity have been proven wrong..with your proof sir..

    Reply
  4. Sean January 25, 2014 at 3:59 pm

    He is so wrong…a huge one exists in Washington DC

    Reply
  5. J. McDonald January 25, 2014 at 3:41 pm

    This article is a hot mess.

    Reply
  6. jamesgeorge January 25, 2014 at 3:29 pm

    there goes hawking again. the only thing he’s sure of is that he’s not sure of anything. he’s always had a penchant for stealing other peoples theories or works anyway. not only is he not called on it he’s actually considered a serious scientist. he’s nowhere near the level of truly great scientists such as newton, kepler, Einstein, Copernicus, galileo, etc. etc. etc.

    Reply
  7. Intelligentcreation January 25, 2014 at 3:24 pm

    Just as Einstein’s theory or relativity is now being found to be incorrect, as newly discovered gravity wells of dual stars has shown, all scientific “facts” pale in time. Black holes just gave us a convenient explanation of something we don’t understand.

    20 years from now, they’ll laugh at what we believed.

    Reply
  8. O Celebi January 25, 2014 at 3:15 pm

    Black holes are nothing more than matter drawn to each other and collapsing at a critical level, just as Einstein predicted that the universe would eventually do but could not explain because of the expansion. It is possible to EXPAND and COLLAPSE independently if you factor in “independence of matter”.

    Reply
  9. Kollin Lore January 25, 2014 at 3:43 pm

    Excuse me good sir, but notoriety has two meanings. It is either someone who is celebrated or widely known, or it is someone who is notorious – unfavourably known. Thank you for your editorial concern.

    Reply

We will read your comment immediately so leave a remark!

RSS Guardian Express

  • Pharmaceutical Drug Samples May Have a Health Cost April 18, 2014
      According to an editorial in the journal JAMA Dermatology, ″Drug Samples in Dermatology,″ pharmaceutical drug companies have been using a clever way to sell more product. They give it away. These free drug samples may have a health cost hidden among the perceived benefits, however. Patients and doctors alike have been tempted to think […]
    Hobie Anthony
  • Matt Flynn Signs With Green Bay Packers April 18, 2014
    After a rollercoaster ride for Matt Flynn, he ends up back where he began, with the Green Bay Packers. Flynn and the Packers came to an agreement on Monday to finalize his fate, at least for the next season. The Green Bay Packers signed Matt Flynn on as their back-up quarterback for the season and […]
    Jabar Morarend
  • Heartburn Linked to Esophageal Cancer April 18, 2014
    April is Esophageal Cancer Awareness Month, and public concern for the disease should be at an all time high. One possible culprit responsible for the increase according to recent medical studies indicates that heartburn is linked to esophageal cancer. In 2006 over 16,000 people were diagnosed with esophageal cancer in the United States according to The Soci […]
    Cholia Johnson
  • Private Lives of Nashville Wives Episode 8: Confrontation & Resolution April 18, 2014
    After last week’s episode left a huge divide between Jenny and the rest of the wives, sans Sarah, episode 8 of Private Lives of Nashville Wives consisted of a confrontation and resolution between the ladies and the start of a new beginning. Having said that, it is doubtful whether or not the type A Jennifer […]
    Michael Smith
  • South Korea Ferry Sinking: Nearly 290 Missing April 18, 2014
    Nearly 290 people are still missing many hours after a ferry sank off South Korea’s southwest coast on Wednesday. At least 14 people are confirmed dead and 55 injured. Officials said there were 475 people on board the ferry, most of them high school pupils, which was heading for the Jeju island when it sent […]
    Rahad Abir

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 627 other subscribers

Quantcast