SpaceX Reusable Grasshopper Proves Hal Clement Right

SpaceX punctuates the year in private space with an apparently modest 29-second flight. On Dec. 17 its reusable Grasshopper engine fired, lifted to a hovering position of 131 feet, then made a controlled landing.

SpaceX had already made its mark cutting the costs of space launch. It still boasts the price of each launch it offers on its website. Grasshopper, as a reusable rocket, simply adds another dimension to SpaceX’s ability to give a better price than any competitor. It isn’t as splashy a success as when Dragon docked with ISS, but it could represent a big shift forward, both in price and in another area that might prove just as important. SpaceX Reusable Grasshopper Proves Hal Clement Right

I once got Hal Clement angry at me. It was at a Science Fiction convention in Baltimore in the early ’90s, and in an elevator. I read the name tag man of the man standing next to me, and correctly figured it was science fiction master Hal Clement. After suitable Oh wows! on my part, I ventured an opinion, “We’ll never get any large number of  people into space using rockets. People aren’t going to want to ride bombs.” In an elevator, yet.

That’s what I had in mind, actually. Elevators – space elevators. The only way great numbers of people would ever go into space themselves would be via the nice, non-explosive lift a space elevator. I felt certain we would be leaving rockets behind relatively soon. By the middle of the 21st century, we would look back in wonder that people ever dared ride such monstrosities.

Hal Clement was perfectly gentlemanly about it, but left no doubt about his view that I was clearly, absolutely, WRONG. Not even a little bit right, not an “Even though your premise about this or that might have merit…” Just wrong, from stem to stern.

This apparently small hop by a rocket really is a giant leap. SpaceX is correct that cost per launch is the key to everything a company can accomplish in space. But in successfully testing a reusable rocket, the Hawthorne, CA firm also crosses another threshold: it is making rockets ordinary. It turns out the goal of making rockets ordinary has always been part of the Grasshopper concept. As SpaceX founder Elon Musk put it a year ago, “If planes were not reusable, very few people would fly.”

Rocket launch will always seem just a bit dangerous so long as large parts of the rocket are destroyed upon launch, cast off as flaming debris and large pieces of metal, into the air, into orbit, wherever. As long as this is the image of a rocket launch, we’ll always have that feeling of people who ride rockets into space, that they’re being awfully brave.

Boeing 727 engine

Boeing 727 engine

We don’t worry about that with airplanes. 727 engines are fired, and turned off, and fired again, daily, over many years. No one really worries about them much. You’re not brave because you flew from McCarran to LAX last week. That’s because, being reusable, it can be thought of us a legitimatemachine and not just a bomb we trained to explode in the right direction, we hope.

Well, I can see the writing on the wall same as anyone. Based upon SpaceX’s success with Grasshopper, I’m going to declare the late Hal Clement the winner in our disagreement. I still like the space elevator. Grasshopper, however, points the way to rocketry really being with us for a very long time as our preferred, even exclusive means to reach space. Once the public starts seeing rocket launches in which the booster rocket engine just drifts down in a controlled landing, is washed off, test-fired, and ready for use again, rocket launches will become safe to the point of ordinary.

Under that paradigm, the rocket might become too standardized as a means to travel into space to be removable, even should a rival emerge. Space elevator people, you’d better get moving.

by Todd Jackson

We will read your comment immediately so leave a remark!

RSS Guardian Express

  • Miley Cyrus: Next Star to Rehab? April 21, 2014
    Miley Cyrus was reported to have told Dolly Parton about her drug use. Parton was concerned for Cyrus after hearing her talk so casual about the use. Is it possible Miley Cyrus will be the next star to go down the rabbit hole of addiction, ending up in rehab? After the outlandish behavior of Cyrus, […]
    Jabar Morarend
  • Innocence Lost Regained April 21, 2014
    Innocence in America in times past, seemed inevitable that the days of black and white would fade into color and reel to reel would evolve into the Blue Ray DVD. Yesteryear, movies were pretty tame in comparison to today’s films with their graphic violence and soft-core porn love scenes. Where are the days of Matt […]
    John Thomas
  • Turn on AMC: Of Cabbages and Kings (Recap/Review) April 21, 2014
    On Turn on AMC tonight, the episode is called Of Cabbages and Kings. The title is likely taken from the Lewis Carroll poem “The Walrus and the Carpenter.” It’s an apropos title, as Abe Woodhull is a cabbage farmer, and the show depicts Americans revolting against the rule of King George III of England, and […]
    Douglas Cobb
  • ‘Hearthstone’ Hits the iPad After Successful Beta April 21, 2014
    Hearthstone: Heroes of Warcraft, Blizzard’s crack at a collectible card game, has received rave reviews since its inception. The game was designed with the mobile platform in mind, and after months of open beta on the PC, Blizzard released the game on the iPad on Wednesday. In less than a week, Hearthstone has already become […]
    Jonathan Gardner
  • Ukraine Crisis Has Rapture Watchers Nervous [Video] April 21, 2014
    The Ukraine Crisis is continuing to draw various interests and concerns from across the world to a head. Notably, the recent events in Eastern Europe has made some rapture watchers nervous. With controversial figures and internet videos touting the recent events as prophecy, the crisis now has a heavy religious following. Figures such as John […]
    Brett Byers-Lane

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 627 other subscribers