Inspector General Russell George says targeting conservative groups “not illegal”


Russell George, the inspector general responsible for investigating the IRS, agreed with ousted IRS commissioner Steven Miller that no laws were broken when the conservative groups were targeted by the IRS.

“It is not illegal, sir, but it was unusual,” George said in response to a question during his testimony in front of Congress.

House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) wants to know “who’s going to jail” over the IRS scandal, but if House Republicans or courts of law can’t prove that laws have been broken, it’s likely that no one will end up going to jail over the IRS targeting conservative groups.

The Constitution’s 1st. Amendment’s guarantee of freedom of speech  may have been violated by the IRS’s targeting of groups like the TEA Party if the IRS’s extra scrutiny of their tax records interfered with this right.

The Constitution’s 14th. amendment may have been violated if  this practice violated the equal protection clause, thou it would have to be proven that the IRS’s policies was evidence of  the government discriminating against its people.

The Constitution’s 4th. amendment may have been violated if  it can be demonstrated in court that the practices of the IRS are seen as “unreasonable search and seizure.”

Even if all of these amendments were broken, violations of the Constitution are  technically not considered to be crimes.

Attorney General Eric Holder stated in his testimony before a House committee Wednesday that three laws that may have been broken.

These are civil rights laws that protect people from being discriminated against by the government; the Hatch Act, which prevents civil servants from engaging in partisan political activity; and perjury laws, which prevent people from lying to Congress.

But while it’s possible for a taxpayer to sue individual employees for allegedly denying them constitutional rights, according to Republican lawyer Jan Baran, who served as general counsel to George H.W. Bush and the RNC, “I am not aware of any statute that prohibits IRS targeting of applicants.”

Proving in a court of law that the IRS’s motivations were political will likely be difficult. If it can’t be proven that the IRS was politically motivated in their targeting of conservative groups for extra scrutiny, getting convictions of IRS officials might be impossible.

The actions of IRS commissioner Steven Miller, when they came to light, caused him to be ousted. His actions could be considered as proof of his incompetence. But, they aren’t necessarily proof of the IRS acting out of political motivation.

That’s why the IRS is trying to argue that the scrutiny of conservative groups  was about incompetence and not due to political motivation.

Written by: Douglas R. Cobb

4 Responses to Inspector General Russell George says targeting conservative groups “not illegal”

  1. Pingback: weight loss

We will read your comment immediately so leave a remark!

RSS Guardian Express

  • Nokia Halts Lumia 2520 Tablet Due to Faulty Chargers April 17, 2014
    Nokia has halted the sale of its new Lumia 2520 tablet due to faulty chargers. Those who currently have the tablet are being warned to stop using the AC-300 charger right now. There are fears that the fault could lead to electric shocks. The good news is there are no confirmed incidents yet. The news […]
    Alexandria Ingham
  • J.K. Rowling Continues Potterverse With Ginny Weasley April 17, 2014
    J.K. Rowling has continued her Potterverse with articles written by Ginny Weasley, under her married name Ginny Potter. The Harry Potter author is continuing with works that she knows will make her money, and focusing on the Quidditch World Cup. It seems like she cannot get enough of her fictional world, and who can blame […]
    Alexandria Ingham
  • Brett Favre and the Green Bay Packers, Can They Reconcile April 17, 2014
    Everyone in Packer land has an opinion on what happened between the Green Bay Packers and Favre. Thompson, Executive Vice President of the team, and Brett Favre were unable to come to an agreement after the 2007 season. The deal left a bad taste for a lot of fans, wondering why Thompson would let their […]
    Jabar Morarend
  • Republican Party Backs Cory Gardner at Colorado State Assembly April 17, 2014
    Last weekend Colorado Republicans held their State Assembly in Greenwood Village to gear up for an ever more closely contested election to be held in November.  The Assembly showed just how strongly the Republican Party backs current U.S. House Representative Cory Gardner within state ranks as their candidate for the available Colorado seat in the […]
    Joseph Porter
  • Bottle of Wine Is NSW Premier’s Undoing April 17, 2014
    Red, red wine, goes to your head, sang UB40 back in the eighties. “Makes you forget..” It certainly had a potent effect on Premier of New South Wales, Barry O’ Farrell’s memory. The NSW premier completely forgot he had been given a bottle of the most expensive wine ever produced in Australia, the legendary Penfold’s […]
    Kate Henderson

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 628 other subscribers