American Idol All Alumni Judges Who Would You Pick (Poll)

Who would like to be a judge on American Idol
With all this talk about Jennifer Hudson being named the first new judge on season 13 of American Idol, we started trying to figure out who else should be given the chance at a seat. So in honour of the new American Idol all alumni panel of judges we decided to find out who you would pick.

The news has been full of who “they” think would be great judges who, like Jennifer, have been through that “trail by fire” of competing and either winning or coming close, who have gone on to carve out careers for themselves.

Kelly Clarkson is the clear favorite. Popular on the show as the first winner ever and she’s got a solid fan base who clearly adore the singer. We figure that she might just be a shoe-in as another of the diminished judges seats, even though she has not been too overjoyed at the prospect of returning.

But we also started thinking about who else might be as popular with other folks.

In at number two on the choice list we have Clay Aiken who won second place on season three of Idol. On May 21, 2003, Aiken came in a close second to Ruben Studdard, who won the contest by 134,000 votes out of more than 24,000,000 votes cast. The result was very controversial, with the answer being that Idol’s voting system was just not capable of handling the number of attempted calls.

With Clay as a clear fan favourite, it would make a lot of sense if the network chose him to be another of the new judges. So if American Idol is going to feature all alumni judges who would you pick as your personal favourite. Would you vote for “Team Clarkson,” or “Team Clay,” would you go for another name that has been mentioned like, for instance, “Team Lambert?”

Because another name that has been bandied about is that of Adam Lambert. Like Clay Aiken, he finished as the runner-up in the eighth season of the show. His time on American Idol was full of controversy after photos of Adam surfaced where he was kissing another man during the American Idol competition. News nuisance and staunch right-winger Bill O-Reilly took umbrage to the photos and called them “embarrassing” but, amazingly he did not agree that the images would impact the competition.

Adam Lambert confirmed that the photos were of him and he stated that he had nothing to hide and had always been open about his life. Mainstream media had a field day while they speculated on his sexuality and the readiness of American Idol voters for an openly gay winner.

When asked by Rolling Stone whether the buzz surrounding his sexual orientation impacted the final vote, Lambert laughed and said “probably.” He confirmed that he was gay in a Rolling Stone cover interview after he was named runner-up.

So we have three choices that have been touted as possible candidates for the show’s change in their format of judging panel. But are there really only three other candidates for the last two judging seats?

We feel like there may be few more candidates that have been ignored for the American Idol all alumni judges seat’s besides Clarkson, Lambert, and Aiken. So we are asking you, dear public to take our poll and tell us who you’d like to see in a judges seat along with Jennifer Hudson. There is nothing to win, but you can tell us who you would like to see on the panel.

[yop_poll id=”13″]

By Michael Smith


440 Responses to "American Idol All Alumni Judges Who Would You Pick (Poll)"

  1. rhinoplasty philadelphia the best center   January 5, 2015 at 2:54 am

    @erfanyasin5 i agree with you..

  2. erfanyasin5   April 7, 2014 at 12:17 pm

    Definitely Adam Lambert should be the doubt

  3. MadamX   July 20, 2013 at 8:58 pm

    There is no doubt in my mind that Adam Lambert will be a judge on Idol. Fox already has him slated to be on Glee next season and the cross promotion of the two biggest franchises on Fox will be a publicity bonanza for the network. The timing also coincides with Adam + Queen performing at iHeart Radio festival; the biggest music festival featuring a who’s who of current music super stars. Not only does that support Adam’s relevance in pop/rock music, it also demonstrates credibility. In addition to all of that, the two new producers of Idol worked with Adam on VH1’s Divas and had nothing but praise for him. I’m guessing the judges will be Adam Lambert, Miley Cyrus & Keith Urban.

  4. anonymous   July 19, 2013 at 2:19 pm

    Adam Lambert by far. Smart, funny, great conversationalist, and nice to look at. Poor Clay is kinda ugly. JS I voted for Clay to win on his singing, but I’d rather see and hear Adam talk. LOL

    • Carole Hart   July 19, 2013 at 8:42 pm

      Definitely Clay. He is the most articulate of all mentioned, is very funny and has some judging experience including at Carnegie Hall. I definitely would start watching again.

  5. Joan Gintella   July 7, 2013 at 9:05 am

    I would like to see Stephen Tyler back. He has more experience as a performer. I think the judges should be Carrie Underwood, Stephen Tyler, Clay Aiken and Jennifer Hudson


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.