From Human to Cyborg? Custom-designed, Enhanced Prosthetics Are in Our Future

Custom-designed, Enhanced Prosthetics Are in Our Future
The technology and engineering behind artificial limbs – or prosthetics – has advanced with amazing speed and, when combined with 3D printing technology and the advances in what is generally called Human Enhancement Technology, a possible future is in sight, in which one could – if one has the money – voluntarily have one or more limbs removed and replaced with custom-designed, enhanced prosthetics. The implications – as well as the ethical questions – are intriguing. How many would volunteer to go from human to cyborg?

It is hard to attempt to predict the number of people who, given the opportunity, would choose to have a healthy limb replaced with a prosthetic that could perform better than the original; faster, stronger, more dexterous and more precise than it’s organic predecessor. If affordability was no object, it might be more popular than one could imagine. Its popularity might even be driven by the need to compete; if numerous people were to obtain prosthetic legs that significantly enhanced their physical abilities, would it not be in one’s own interest to do the same or be considered inferior?

prostheitc limb cusotm design3D printing technology is certain to make replacement limbs considerably more affordable. The technology also allows for almost limitless customization in the design of artificial limbs. Industrial designer Scott Summit is designing prosthetics which reflect something of the personality of their owners – in shape, color, decorative devices and materials used. These custom-designed prosthetics appear to have a positive affect; their owners are not only more comfortable with the devices, but actually come to view them as an integral part of their own identity.

Whilst even the most advanced prosthetics widely available today are designed to restore physical ability, rather than enhance it, the ability to create artificial limbs that perform better than the originals is certainly a potential reality. Various advances currently being worked on include neural interfacing, which aims to design ways in which the central nervous system can control the operation of an artificial limb and even receive sensory information from it. Use of new materials, such as high-strength, lightweight carbon-fiber, developed by NASA, offers the possibility of greater endurance and enhanced physical ability. German athlete Wojtek Czyz, using a prosthetic leg made of such material, broke world records in sprint and long jump at the 2008 Paralympics.

Revolutionary prosthetic arm developed by APL
This prosthetic limb from APL comes close to functioning like a real hand but still lacks sensory ability

Human enhancement technology approaches the concept from a different direction – or, at least, it has so far. Drugs designed to enhance cognitive function, retinal implants for enhanced vision and wearable technology, such as exoskeletons or even suits, are ideas that remain either as realistic concepts or in various stages of development. The military is currently working on the development of exoskeletons and “smart” armor designed to enhance soldiers’ protection and physical capability. Defense contractor Raytheon has already developed such a project. The company’s second-generation exoskeleton (XOS 2), though seemingly cumbersome, is, perhaps, a mere glimpse at what may be coming in the not too distant future.

Futurist and author Ray Kurzweil proposes a theory that is based on what he calls “the law of accelerating returns.” According to Kurzweil’s “law” – in simple terms – the rate of technological advancement can and often does become exponential; an evolutionary process, essentially, in which “positive feedback” fuels an increased rate of advancement as the best, most successful technologies developed are, themselves, used to develop new technologies. The advancement in computing technology through the 20th Century is a good demonstration of this theory. One possible – and, perhaps, probable – outcome is the increasing fusion of the engineering technology that enhances speed and strength with micro-technology and human design, producing functional but enhanced limbs designed to the wearer’s personal tastes. This merging of technologies essentially began in the 1990s. Even in the face of incredible advancements in prosthetics technology, perhaps only a minority of people would trade their limbs for enhanced and custom-designed prosthetics, but, for the disabled, it represents an incredible vision of the future.

Transhumanism, which grew up in the 1980s and gathered steam in the 1990s, suggests an optimistic future where the continued merger of the human body and advanced robotics technology extends

3D printed prosthetic leg
Prosthetic leg made by 3D printer

mortality, reduces or eliminates disease and infection and generally serves to enhance quality of life. Protecting against the risk of infection remains one of the greatest challenges in the development of prosthetics that directly connect to the human central nervous system.

One of the main arguments against such a vision of the future is that the more human beings modify themselves artificially, the less humanity they will retain. Kurzweil predicts a future milestone know as the “Singularity”; a point that will mark “the union of human and machine.”

Human beings will, in reality, choose to modify their bodies in the name of health, vanity, self-image improvement or all of those things; tattoos, piercings, cosmetic surgery, silicon implants and botox injections are all

methods that humans use, for a variety of reasons, to alter and – in their view – enhance their bodies. A cursory survey of comments posted on various sites, regarding this topic, suggests that the majority of people would only opt for even a “bionic” limb if they lost one of their own limbs in an accident. How widely, though, might such a radical procedure be accepted in the future?

Editorial by Graham J Noble

Institute for Ethics & Emerging Technologies
Popular Science
Johns Hopkins

5 Responses to "From Human to Cyborg? Custom-designed, Enhanced Prosthetics Are in Our Future"

  1. Tris valentine   June 13, 2015 at 10:51 am

    The character from ghost in the shell, Mokuto kusanagi has a brain and central nervous system which is an integration rather than a straight-up replacement. Her original brain has been operated upon and enclosed in a super thin shell. Her organic brain matter is still present, but in the end of the original movie she leaves her physical body behind and moves to the net. Also there are numerous parts of the sequels and Mini series where she controls multiple bodies simultaneously. She references her “ghost” multiple times in the movie, a concept she explains as her “sense of self”. There are parts of some the movies where she references having “grown beyond her physical boundaries” where she implies that her existence has continued via the infrastructure of the “net”, rather than through a physical body. The uncertainty of characters she has met previously as to her identity, confirm that her origins are to have been given a cyborg body( as a child..which then begs the question how did her brain grow and adapt to such a container), only to eventually live on in the net as a “ghost” after having been a counter-intelligence operative for her adult life. So really kusanagi’s body is one prosthesis eventually. Even her cyberbrain. Which is pretty cool. And deep. And as someone who is deaf in one ear I would love to get a cyborg prosthesis, provided it was better than the original (minus all those sticky, inconvenient facts that get in the way such as your body rejecting the implants).

  2. Donald Shin   May 24, 2014 at 6:41 pm

    Is it possible to volunteer?

  3. Earlene Will   February 8, 2014 at 8:51 am

    I’d like to see these developments being used for the thousands (probably hundreds of thousands) of people wearing the cheapest prosthetics that Medicare will allow because the disabled wearer has no other medical coverage or the where-with-all to pay out of pocket. There are 1.7 million people in the US living with limb loss, so it would be wonderful if these kinds of prosthetics were available to all, and not only those with excess funds.

  4. Brad Arnold   February 8, 2014 at 5:57 am

    I would think the amputation of a perfectly good limb would be unnecessary, as an augmentation could be put over the flesh. You really got to be hardcore to sacrifice part of yourself unnecessarily to gain debateable benefits.

    BTW, in the fictional world of Ghost in a Shell (GIS), people have cyberbrains installed, and I always wondered if to do that they needed to have part of their real brain removed. Any thoughts?

    • weatherlite   June 12, 2014 at 9:01 am

      in ghost in the shell, the main character, can’t remember her name but the female lead only had a small piece of her original brain matter left, which lead her to a philosophical debate about if she is actually alive or not, or something like that.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login